Skip to main content
Test Double company logo
Services
Services Overview
Holistic software investment consulting
Software Delivery
Accelerate quality software development
Product Management
Launch modern product orgs
Legacy Modernization
Renovate legacy software systems
DevOps
Scale infrastructure smoothly
Upgrade Rails
Update Rails versions seamlessly
Technical Recruitment
Build tech & product teams
Technical Assessments
Uncover root causes & improvements
Case Studies
Solutions
Accelerate Quality Software
Software Delivery, DevOps, & Product Delivery
Maximize Software Investments
Product Performance, Product Scaling, & Technical Assessments
Future-Proof Innovative Software
Legacy Modernization, Product Transformation, Upgrade Rails, Technical Recruitment
About
About
What's a test double?
Approach
Meeting you where you are
Founder's Story
The origin of our mission
Culture
Culture & Careers
Double Agents decoded
Great Causes
Great code for great causes
EDI
Equity, diversity & inclusion
Insights
All Insights
Hot takes and tips for all things software
Leadership
Bold opinions and insights for tech leaders
Developer
Essential coding tutorials and tools
Product Manager
Practical advice for real-world challenges
Say Hello
Test Double logo
Menu
Services
BackGrid of dots icon
Services Overview
Holistic software investment consulting
Software Delivery
Accelerate quality software development
Product Management
Launch modern product orgs
Legacy Modernization
Renovate legacy software systems
Cycle icon
DevOps
Scale infrastructure smoothly
Upgrade Rails
Update Rails versions seamlessly
Technical Recruitment
Build tech & product teams
Technical Assessments
Uncover root causes & improvements
Case Studies
Solutions
Solutions
Accelerate Quality Software
Software Delivery, DevOps, & Product Delivery
Maximize Software Investments
Product Performance, Product Scaling, & Technical Assessments
Future-Proof Innovative Software
Legacy Modernization, Product Transformation, Upgrade Rails, Technical Recruitment
About
About
About
What's a test double?
Approach
Meeting you where you are
Founder's Story
The origin of our mission
Culture
Culture
Culture & Careers
Double Agents decoded
Great Causes
Great code for great causes
EDI
Equity, diversity & inclusion
Insights
Insights
All Insights
Hot takes and tips for all things software
Leadership
Bold opinions and insights for tech leaders
Developer
Essential coding tutorials and tools
Product Manager
Practical advice for real-world challenges
Say hello
Leadership
Leadership
Leadership
Rails upgrades

Why Rails upgrades are harder than you think

Rails upgrades seem straightforward—until they aren’t. Hidden costs, delays, and burnout can make in-house upgrades a nightmare. Here’s how to avoid it.
Test Double Editorial Board
|
February 19, 2025
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Rails upgrades seem like they should be simple. In theory, you just bump the version number, resolve some gem conflicts, and call it a day.

In reality? The upgrade drags on for months, feature development slows to a crawl, and your team starts muttering things like “Maybe we should just rewrite this in Elixir” under their breath.

We’ve been in the trenches of some of the biggest Rails upgrades in the world—helping companies like GitHub, Gusto, and Zendesk avoid upgrade hell. 

We’ve seen firsthand how in-house teams underestimate the complexity, overpromise on timelines, and ultimately spend way too much time and energy just trying to make their app work again.

Let’s talk about why Rails upgrades are trickier than they look, the hidden costs of attempting them in-house, and why so many companies end up calling us to save the day.

The hidden complexity of a Rails upgrade

Let’s be real: Most engineering leaders don’t want to do a Rails upgrade. They have to. Maybe they’ve outgrown an older version, maybe they need security fixes, or maybe someone on the compliance team just discovered that running an unsupported framework isn’t exactly best practice.

Whatever the reason, leadership says, "We need to upgrade."

So your team starts planning. And this is where things go off the rails (pun fully intended).

What gets underestimated every time:

Breaking changes lurk everywhere. Each new Rails version comes with deprecations, behavior shifts, and subtle gotchas that can break your app in weird, unexpected ways.

Your dependencies don’t care about your timeline. That one gem your app critically depends on? Yeah, it hasn't been updated in four years, and now you're rewriting half your codebase just to replace it.

Your test suite isn’t as good as you thought. If your test coverage is spotty, you won’t know what you broke until it’s in production—where your customers will kindly inform you via support tickets and Twitter rants.

Your app isn’t just Rails. Database versions, background jobs, third-party integrations—these all have to be audited and tested to avoid nasty surprises post-upgrade.

Feature work grinds to a halt. Your best engineers get pulled into upgrade purgatory, leaving the rest of the team to either twiddle their thumbs or try (and fail) to ship new features without them.

Upgrades can break brand-new features. Just because an upgrade is “done” doesn’t mean it stays done—ongoing feature work can introduce subtle incompatibilities that force teams to revisit completed upgrades.

Upgrading isn’t just technical—it’s political. Every risky or disruptive change needs buy-in from stakeholders who may not fully understand the complexity. Without clear communication, upgrades get derailed fast.

This is why a “quick upgrade” turns into a multi-month slog. By the time the app is finally running on the new version, everyone is exhausted, the codebase is messier than before, and leadership is wondering why this took longer than the last actual product launch.

The real cost of upgrading Rails in-house

So let’s talk about what this upgrade actually costs when you try to do it yourself.

Lost productivity. Every month your team spends upgrading is a month they aren’t building new features, fixing customer pain points, or improving performance.

Missed deadlines. Upgrades rarely go according to plan. Dependencies break, regressions appear, and suddenly your “quick upgrade” is pushing back product roadmaps.

Developer burnout. Engineers don’t exactly love spending months fighting deprecation warnings. Upgrades are tedious, high-pressure, and feel like thankless work—especially when leadership keeps asking, “Isn’t it done yet?”

Post-upgrade surprises. Even if you technically finish the upgrade, you’re not out of the woods. Performance issues, unexpected behavior changes, and sneaky bugs have a way of surfacing after you go live.

It’s going to get messy. Let’s be honest—no one wants to touch the cruftiest parts of the codebase. But upgrades force teams to dig into technical debt that’s been ignored for years, which only adds to the time and complexity.

The bottom line? If you don’t approach an upgrade strategically, it will cost you more time, money, and stress than you expect.

This is why companies like GitHub, Gusto, and Zendesk called us when they needed their Rails upgrades done right.

‍How Test Double makes Rails upgrades actually manageable

Our approach is different because we don’t just get the upgrade done—we make sure your app is in better shape than when we started.

Here’s how we do it:

We plan for real-world constraints. We don’t just blindly bump versions—we map out the safest upgrade path, minimize disruptions, and keep feature work moving.

We proceed in an incremental and interruptible fashion. If something comes up, your team isn’t locked in upgrade purgatory for six months—you won’t lose the work we’ve done.

We identify and fix hidden tech debt. Upgrades are a great opportunity to clean up legacy code, improve test coverage, and set your team up for long-term success.

We communicate effectively. We make sure everyone who needs to know—engineering, product, leadership—understands why a change is risky, how it will affect them, and how we’ll mitigate issues.

We hit deadlines without cutting corners. Gusto needed their upgrade delivered on time and under budget. We made it happen (and fixed 1,700 test failures along the way).

We leave your team stronger than before. Our goal isn’t just to finish the upgrade—it’s to make sure your engineers have the knowledge and techniques to avoid falling three versions behind again.

As GitHub’s Eileen Uchitelle—who, by the way, is literally a Ruby core maintainer—famously put it: “Hot take: just have Test Double build all your stuff.”

We couldn’t have said it better ourselves.

Thinking about a Rails upgrade? Let’s talk.

If your team is staring down a Rails upgrade and wondering “How bad is this going to be?”—we should chat.

We’ve done this for some of the biggest Rails codebases in the world. We know the pitfalls, we know how to avoid them, and we know how to make this way less painful for your team.

So before your senior engineers mysteriously disappear for “just a quick break” (only to return six months later after an existential crisis), let’s talk.

We can help make your upgrade smooth, fast, and drama-free. Contact us now. 

Avoid the pain

Upgrade smarter, not harder. Keep your team shipping while we handle the mess.

Rails Upgrades: The Good Parts

Related Insights

🔗
Why Rails upgrades are so important
🔗
Why it’s worth outsourcing your Rails upgrades
🔗
Guide to incremental Rails upgrades for smoother transitions
🔗
Zero downtime Rails upgrades

Explore our insights

See all insights
Developers
Developers
Developers
C# and .NET tools and libraries for the modern developer

C# has a reputation for being used in legacy projects and is not often talked about related to startups or other new business ventures. This article aims to break a few of the myths about .NET and C# and discuss how it has evolved to be a great fit for almost any kind of software.

by
Patrick Coakley
Leadership
Leadership
Leadership
Turning observability into a team strength without a big overhaul

By addressing observability pain points one at a time, we built systems and practices that support rapid troubleshooting and collaboration.

by
Gabriel Côté-Carrier
Developers
Developers
Developers
Why I actually enjoy PR reviews (and you should, too)

PR reviews don't have to be painful. Discover practical, evidence-based approaches that turn code reviews into team-building opportunities while maintaining quality and reducing development friction.

by
Robert Komaromi
Letter art spelling out NEAT

Join the conversation

Technology is a means to an end: answers to very human questions. That’s why we created a community for developers and product managers.

Explore the community
Test Double Executive Leadership Team

Learn about our team

Like what we have to say about building great software and great teams?

Get to know us
Test Double company logo
Improving the way the world builds software.
What we do
Services OverviewSoftware DeliveryProduct ManagementLegacy ModernizationDevOpsUpgrade RailsTechnical RecruitmentTechnical Assessments
Who WE ARE
About UsCulture & CareersGreat CausesEDIOur TeamContact UsNews & AwardsN.E.A.T.
Resources
Case StudiesAll InsightsLeadership InsightsDeveloper InsightsProduct InsightsPairing & Office Hours
NEWSLETTER
Sign up hear about our latest innovations.
Your email has been added!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Standard Ruby badge
614.349.4279hello@testdouble.com
Privacy Policy
© 2020 Test Double. All Rights Reserved.

Avoid the pain

Upgrade smarter, not harder. Keep your team shipping while we handle the mess.

Rails Upgrades: The Good Parts